Published on 01 Sep 13
by "AUSTRALIAN TAX FORUM" JOURNAL ARTICLE
Taxpayers’ tax attributes (the focus in this paper is on tax losses, both revenue and CGT losses) are extinguished on death, and they are not available to the deceased’s [trust] estate or beneficiaries. This extinguishment rule stands in stark contrast to the rules that apply upon the death of a stakeholder in a company or a fixed trust with tax losses. Here, through the fiction of “continuity of life”, there is no extinguishment rule. Further, the extinguishment rule is also anomalous in the context of the extremely generous treatment given to the “event of death” throughout many other areas of the income tax. The death of a taxpayer is overwhelmingly treated as an occasion where relief is given. No doubt, the extremely generous treatment is, in part, designed to avoid the appearance of a “death duty”. Yet, the extinguishment rule has not attracted the same concessional treatment.
This article compares the tax treatment of death where tax losses are owned directly with the situation where tax losses are “owned” through entities. The article also compares the extinguishment rule with the concessional treatment of death involved in a number of the most important areas of the income tax. The conclusion of the article is that the current extinguishment rule is inequitable and anomalous, and its continuance is difficult to justify.
Dale Boccabella CTA
Dale is an Associate Professor in the School of Taxation and Business Law, UNSW Business School, University of New South Wales. He has designed an extensive range of courses and teaching materials for both undergraduate and postgraduate courses on Australian taxation law over the past 23 years, including taxation of partnerships, taxation of trusts, taxation of companies and company distributions. Dale has published over 130 articles/papers, including 36 refereed articles, 45 technical commentaries, conference and seminar papers, media commentaries etc on Australia's tax regime(s). These publications deal with a wide range of tax areas and reflect Dale's research interests. Current at 01 April 2016
Click here to expand/collapse more articles by Dale BOCCABELLA.