CGT - Mature Adult or Unruly Adolescent?

Published on 01 Apr 05 by "AUSTRALIAN TAX FORUM" JOURNAL ARTICLE

The Australian capital gains tax is approaching its 20th birthday. This paper reflects on why the CGT provisions were introduced and considers how they have impacted upon taxpayers and tax practitioners. It argues that there has been progress in removing some of the inconsistencies and anomalies in the CGT regime, but that a number of problems still exist. The paper explores a variety of technical areas that are still problematic, including issues surrounding the grandfathered status of pre-CGT assets, technical difficulties with the operation of the small business concessions, and problems relating to the application of the CGT provisions to trusts.

The causes of these technical difficulties lie in inappropriate policy selection, poor or incomplete legislative drafting, poor implementation and administration of the provisions and 'legislative layering' - whereby new policy and legislation is superimposed upon an existing framework that is insufficiently robust or compatible.

Technical solutions can be attempted, but ultimately, the paper argues, the remedy to many of the technical problems does not lie in ad hoc and reactive fixes, but in a more principled approach to the design of the CGT regime.

This paper was also presented on 17 March 2005 at the 20th National Convention in Perth.

Author profile

Prof Christopher Evans

Chris is a Professor, School of Taxation & Business Law, UNSW Australia, Extraordinary Professor, Department of Taxation, University of Pretoria, and Senior Research Fellow, Tax Law and Policy Research Group, Monash University. - Current at 29 May 2019

More by Chris EVANS

• To cap or not to cap? Policy options for dealing with the costs of managing tax affairs deduction in Australia - 01-July-2020
• The impact of tax rate changes on capital gains realisations: evidence from Australia - 01-December-2018
• Mitigating VAT compliance costs – A developing country perspective - 01-July-2017
• The impact of recent tax changes on tax complexity and compliance costs: The tax practitioners’ perspective - 01-October-2016
• Taxing personal capital gains in Australia: An alternative way forward - 01-December-2015
• Are your affairs CGT small business concession ready? paper - 28-August-2014
• Tangled up in tape: The continuing tax compliance plight of the small and medium enterprise business sector - 01-May-2014
• Personal taxpayer compliance costs: Recent evidence from Australia - 01-April-2014
• An evaluation of the contribution of Justice Hill to the provisions for the taxing of capital gains in Australia - 01-June-2013
• Quenching a thirst or drinking to excess? Utilising the CGT small business concessions to maximum effect paper - 23-May-2013
• Foreigners don't vote: the removal of the CGT discount for non-residents. - 07-May-2013
• The rise and rise of tax compliance costs for the small business sector in Australia - 01-August-2012
• Tax reform and ‘rough justice’: Is it time for simplicity to shine? - 01-April-2012
• Tax policy simplification: An evaluation of the proposal for a standard deduction for work related expenses - 01-December-2011
• Managing tax system complexity: Building bridges through pre-filled tax returns - 01-July-2010
• Tax reviews in Australia : before and after Henry. - 08-October-2009
• Living with capital gains (and losses): topical issues paper - 14-August-2009
• Yearning for earnout certainty - 01-June-2008
• Effective marginal tax rates and work disincentives - 01-July-2007
• Towards systemic reform of the Australian personal income tax - 01-April-2007
• Alive and thriving – the revised regime for CGT small business concessions - 01-April-2007
• CGT small business changes from the budget paper - 15-March-2007
• Personal income tax reform in Australia: The way forward - 01-July-2006
• CGT - mature adult or unruly adolescent? paper - 17-March-2005
• Taxing personal capital gains in Australia: causes of complexity and proposals for reform - 01-July-2004
• A CGT Survival Guide seminar paper - 15-June-2004
• Cedric Sandford (1924-2004) - Gentleman and Scholar - 01-April-2004
• In with the new, out with the old? - 01-May-2003
• The impact of Cedric Sandford on the Discipline of Tax Compliance Costs - 01-October-2002
• Continuous CGT Planning - 24-May-2002
• Assessing the potential compliance costs/benefits of the tax value method - 01-January-2002
• Taxing Capital Gains: One Step Forwards or Two Steps Back? - 01-January-2002
• Small Business CGT Concessions - A Little Ray of Sunshine - 01-August-2001
• CGT Small Business Concessions / Discount - 03-May-2001
• Getting the best from the CGT concessions - 15-February-2001
• Capital Gains Tax - "Choosing the Right Course" - 21-October-2000
• CGT After Ralph- The New Regime - 01-June-2000
• The new regime: CGT after Ralph - 01-June-2000
• Tax compliance costs: research methodology and empirical evidence from Australia - 01-June-2000
• The CGT implications of Ralph - 28-February-2000
• The CGT implications of Ralph - 15-February-2000
• CGT after Ralph - the new regime - 28-January-2000
• CGT after Ralph- the new regime- Indicative solutions to the case study - 28-January-2000
• Small Business Roll-overs and Exceptions - 16-July-1999
• Small business rollovers and exemptions - 16-July-1999
• CGT the case study way: creative rollovers - 24-March-1999
• The Australian capital gains tax: rationale, review and reform - 01-July-1998
• Rolling the dice with CGT - 29-May-1998
• Rolling the dice with CGT - 29-May-1998
• CGT update including TLIP - 15-May-1998
• CGT update including TLIP - 15-May-1998
• Taxation compliance costs: some recent empirical work and international comparisons - 01-January-1998
• Small business CGT roll-over relief: is the packaging of qualifying conditions a gangrene-inducing tourniquet or a necessary bandage? - 01-October-1997
• Compliance costs and taxation impact statements - 01-January-1997
• Tax in review: rollover relief! - 01-June-1996

Click here to expand/collapse more articles by Chris EVANS.